23.2.09

Productive Ignorance/ Productive Failure

“I have missed more than 9000 shots in my career. I have lost almost 300 games. On 26 occasions I have been entrusted to take the game winning shot...and missed. And I have failed over and over and over again in my life. And that is why... I succeed.”
--Michael Jordan

Both Michael Jordan and a microbiologist named Martin A. Schwartz believe that taking risks and failing -- whether by missing shots in a basketball game or trying to solve intractable scientific problems -- is the key to succeeding. As Schwartz puts it, the reason for taking exams (i.e. comprehensive or qualifying exams for a thesis or dissertation) in the first place is to see if the student "fails at a sufficiently high level." It is the nerve to take risks in the first place that is the only path to breaking through to a new level.

The importance of stupidity in science, Journal of Cell Science 121, 1771 (2008).

12.2.09

Migration: the complex and the simple

After participating in a march in Ixtepec, Oaxaca in southern Mexico with mothers and family members who are searching for their missing daughters and sons, I was struck at both the complexity of the structural issues in migration, and also the very straight-forward issues being addressed by legions of people who offer direct services to migrants. These Salvadorean women were coming on bus through Mexico, and started in Chiapas (article in spanish). I´ll offer some thoughts on the basic issues before reflecting on the complex.

Searching for your child: This morning, around 9am we watched as a group of somber women and men from El Salvador descended from their bus. They were met by Mexican supporters, including the priest and local workers from the Ixtepec migrant shelter. Located in part of Mexico that narrows considerably - the Isthmus - Ixtepec sits in the path of the railroad tracks that carry Mexico´s frieght train. Although riding the train is dangerous and uncomfortable, it does not cost anything, and thus is the method of choice for many migrants. The Salvadorean group had decided to come through Ixtepec since there was a high chance that their loved one had passed through. As the mothers assembled for their march, they held up signs that took my breath away. Each sign said their child´s name, when they were lost, and had their picture. These mothers have been looking for the news of their children for as long as 28 years in one case, and refuse to give up hope. As we found out during the march and ensuing speeches and testimonies, they have tried every means possible including following the migrant trail and calling authorities in Mexico and the United States. Their resolution in searching for their children presents a very straight-forward human universal: a parent's love.

Why does someone migrate? This is much more complex issue, perhaps, and involves much more than might be commonly imagined. I'll stick to facts that are less well-known. For the majority of people who migrate, the motivation is fundamentally economic. However, they also may be fleeing domestic, local (e.g. gang-related), political or structural violence in their home communities. The migrants coming through Mexico often have migrated more than once and come from many different parts of Latin America, and even Africa and Asia. Most are from Central America, and face mistreatment by vendors, migration officials, military personnel, fellow travelers, and police. Up to 90% of women encounter sexual violence. Depending on which country the migrant is coming from, large-scale economic forces, structural adjustment, or national level politics may be strong push-factors.


The image above shows migrants jumping on the roof of the moving train.

1.2.09

About the author

This blog is maintained by Nick Rattray. Nick is working on his dissertation in cultural anthropology at the University of Arizona, focused on social exclusion for people with disabilities in Ecuador. He has worked in applied research and community development for the last decade in California, New Jersey, Arizona, and Ecuador. Nick has published articles on accessibility and community-based mapping, and is currently working on an article on social inclusion in Ecuador. He received his B.A. in anthropology from UC Berkeley, a Masters in Urban Planning from Rutgers University, and hopefully will complete his PhD in 2010. In his free time, he enjoys spending time with his family, playing basketball and soccer, traveling, gardening, and painting.